Obviously. I never said otherwise.
If someone wants to know how they feel on carnivore, they must do it. The other people’s experiences may be useful but say not much about how we would feel on it. And we may extrapolate from our experiences on a different woe, it may be even close to the truth - or not. You said that, others here said that and even trying it for shorter times, extreme low-carb is nothing like just being in ketosis with plants to me too.
I thought about the people who tries too hard without any need. Maybe most of us here didn’t make a jump that was brutal. My approach is very hedonistic but apart from that, a gradual change is what worked for me, I couldn’t even do keto right after high-carb (I tried. gave up on the first day and it was the best I could do. maybe I should have try a tad earlier again…).
We humans are complicated. Even if something IS the ideal for us, doing it too hard may be damaging mentally, emotionally, possibly physically because they can’t do it right then.
There is the sickness(?) with the own name where people focus on health too much or rather too wrong? Just because someone ditches plants, they won’t be automatically free from the chance of a bad mindset.
Yeah, that’s bad. Me as an ex-vegetarian wasn’t fond of people who ate meat and talked about being a vegetarian and even a vegan… Not like it matters if I ever was a vegetarian, I dislike such things anyway. I didn’t ever need much advice about any of my woe, I am a stubborn experimenting type (of course, it’s nice to know how others work, it should be similar to how we work to some extent, even but no bad advice can ruin my woe and health) BUT I was misunderstood due to other people with the same label but with a different eating style (that went against the one damn rule we had) and it was annoying sometimes.
And anyway, if someone decide on doing something, do it right - or if they fail, don’t say they are doing it. And people who really give advice should be know what are they doing as they influence others. The others should just talk about their experiences if they prefer but if possible, not in a way that says it’s the One True Way. I saw that way too often.
I still have no idea what “85% carnivore” means (well, it’s a bit like 85% vegetarian or 85% virgin, okay maybe not but I was, like, 60% carnivore on vegetarian keto then? not like I know what percentages mean, it was just a number but it’s… it’s not that at all)… Whatever. 85% is very little, no matter how we look at it and for me, it feels nothing like 99% carnivore (as I notice differences right away or almost right away, even I can tell this in my own case. A significant amount of plants easily messes up everything)… And people experienced that 99% and 100% is different too so… It makes no sense to me. And it’s no carnivore of course. (It’s a bit simpler to be a vegetarian, there are no allowed amount of meat there… Well most cheeses are not vegetarian so no, that’s not simple either in the end… Humans overcomplicate anything anyway, we are very good at that.)
I wouldn’t experience what a carnivore experiences anyway as they aren’t me and I eat differently unless a woe is VERY specific… That’s why I try out things myself. The experience of others (and eventually myself) that even some plants can mess up things were very helpful. In many cases we experience similar things to others, that’s why people can help each other with their woe. But we won’t all experience the same. We are on different part of our journey too, that’s the 3rd factor in my list that explain differences… Veterans can talk about their newbie times but maybe they come from a very different previous woe…