Maybe it is. We simply don’t know. You could say the exact same thing about Keto.
“Sure it seems to help a bunch of people’s health in huge ways, but is it best?”
It’s not similar at all. First of all Advil is a medication that gives short term relief with long term consequences of overuse. Carnivore seems to give complete resolution of a dizzying variety of conditions getting people off medications they have been stuck with for years and leaves them feeling great. This is why we all love keto so much and think that it’s the healthier human diet. Well some of us on taking the further step to carnivore experience health gains that far outstrip what they obtained on keto alone. And it’s very clear from just looking at this forum that this is not a small population.
I’m not saying carnivore is healthier than keto. In fact I think there are probably healthy and unhealthy ways of practicing both. But which is best? We have no idea.
Absolutely, but the same can be said about the ketogenic diet.