How do we stop this nonsense?


(KM) #21

Some random googling, the rate of death by heart disease in Denmark is approximately half that of cancer. Of course this could simply speak to a severe carcinogenic element, but combined with the long lifespan it seems to me this is supportive of the idea that cheese is not the enemy, at least in this genetic population.


(Bob M) #22

The French have all kinds of exceptions to the ā€œrulesā€. They eat a lot of cheese, dairy (cream in particular), which have lots of saturated fat; eat bread, desserts, meats, etc. Smoke a lot too.

On this list, France is number 1:

image

Denmark is not on the list though. In fact, with a brief search, I can’t find anything about cheese intake in Denmark, though did find some lists of cheeses to try if I ever get there. :grinning:

Unfortunately, I found this from the Danish Veterinary and Food Administration:

That’s too bad.


#23

It’s unreal and just a reflection of what is happening world wide, being pushed by a centralized organization and ā€œstakeholdersā€

It’s absolutely ridiculous to mix up climate initiatives with diets. :woman_facepalming:t3:


(Bob M) #24

Yeah, there’s a lack of evidence for all of that.

And, after listening to quite a few podcasts about beef in particular, I think ruminants like cows protect the planet, not destroy it.

It’s interesting that they admit there are stakeholders. In the US, they hide those at least.


(KM) #25

Personally I’d be less alarmed or annoyed by this if proven methodologies for pasturing cows responsibly were exempted. It’s not the cows, it’s the overcrowding and the inappropriate feeding that cause the issues. And I’m going to say it again. I want to see proof that cows produce more methane on the whole than the carb-addicted human population.


(Edith) #26

I’m wondering why these are lumped in together? I don’t think I want veterinarians advising what humans should be eating. :laughing:


(You've tried everything else; why not try bacon?) #27

They might do a better job than doctors!


(Edith) #28

Ha, ha, good point! :laughing:


(Geoffrey) #29

Almost? It actually IS a religion. Has been since it’s inception.


(Bob M) #30

I thought that was weird too. But we have the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which oddly handles food policy (tying it to drugs?), instead of the Department of Agriculture, where food seems to fit.


(Geoffrey) #31

Everyone just needs to leave my cows alone or I’ll have them fart in your general direction. :face_with_raised_eyebrow:
IMG_0262


(Central Florida Bob ) #32

Annual per Capita? Annual what? What’s France first at?


(Bob M) #33

Sorry. Cheese consumption. Annual per capita pounds of cheese. 2.5 ounces of cheese per day per person per year. Not that much, really.


(Central Florida Bob ) #34

:+1:

Thanks.


(Joey) #35

Red wine must be highly protective :wink:


(You've tried everything else; why not try bacon?) #36

Not to mention smoking Gauloises . . . :smoking:


(Robin) #37

Okay, but do they have the holy grail?


(Bob M) #38

Red wine is one of those (many) things that confuse me, It’s actually in some versions of the Mediterranean Diet, but not in others. Like this, for instance:

But there’s recently some arguments there shouldn’t be red wine in the Med Diet:

Of course, that article makes little sense, as it’s all based on epidemiology and they are saying people under 35 shouldn’t drink wine while people over should. Ah, what?

But they may actually run an RCT:

image

That would be interesting.


(Central Florida Bob ) #39

Considering the shoreline of the Mediterranean is nearly 29,000 miles long and covers old cultures from north Africa, east through Israel, Turkey, Greece, and the Adriatic countries, then all the way back west to Spain, it’s hard for me to imagine there’s just one Mediterranean diet. How much do Libyans eat like Italians or Cypriots after all? When I read The Big Fat Surprise, (Nina Teicholz’ big seller) I wasn’t surprised to find that the whole concept was a plot by olive oil sellers to not get excluded from the ā€œhealthy foodsā€ craze. Figuratively, ā€œlet’s have a conference and feed the doctors with the best tasting food we can find, then tell them it’s the Mediterranean way of eating!ā€

The only thing I have absolute faith in is the ability of epidemiologists to mess up an RCT.


#40

It’s just a name like paleo diet. Of course it doesn’t mean people eat/ate like that in some area or time period…
Probably there is some vague connection with some true Mediterranean diets and that’s it…? Never was particularly interested in The Mediterrean diet, I know it has some nice points vs the usual awful modern diets… It surely works for some and not at all for others.

I am all for individual diets, fine tuned to the needs, desires, circumstances etc. of the one in question. It’s not simple at all but some simple general advice can seriously damage someone even if it’s great for many…

I like some very low-carb vaguely Hungarian style diet even I don’t know about it being some specific one :upside_down_face: I definitely depend on pork WAY more than the average Hungarians but eat about as much fat. Pork, fat, lots of sour cream and quark, paprika, some fowls, some fish and not caring about dietary guides, soups regularly… Pretty much Hungarian, just without most of the carbs! (And without much booze. I probably drink less alcohol than the average 15-17 years old, not like I have data about them but some of them drink very heavily and surely most of the others drink too. Is it part of the diet? Must be as it brings calories…)