Cutting carbs can increase your risk of diabetes


(Chris) #17

Article from the Sydney Morning Herald 8/12/17 pointing out if you dont eat carbs you will get diabetes and cancer! That just not Keto

Australians risk increasing their chances of developing diabetes, cardiovascular disease and colon cancer if they cut quality carbohydrates high in cereal fibre from their diets, experts say.

A group of leading international and Australian experts say the evidence on the health benefits of eating whole grains is “unequivocal” and those who avoid them are increasing their risk of disease.

Experts are warning against the trend of Australians cutting quality carbohydrates.
In a bid to increase the consumption of whole grains, the International Carbohydrate Quality Consortium (ICQC) - a group of about 30 nutrition academics, epidemiologists and scientists - has released a consensus report on their health benefits.

The report follows two days of discussions in Italy in September between ICQC members, including US physician Professor Walter Willett at Harvard University’s School of Public Health…
Professor Jennie Brand Miller from the University of Sydney’s Charles Perkins Centre and School of Life and Environmental Sciences - one of three Australian members of the consortium - says unfortunately there is a “very noisy” group trying to convince people to completely cut carbohydrates.

“We think that the current environment is giving the general public the impression that all grains are best avoided when in fact the research is very clear that when you include whole grain it is associated with lower risk of cardiovascular disease, diabetes and of weight gain,” Professor Miller told AAP.

“The science is unequivocal when it comes to diabetes and cardiovascular disease.”

Fruit and vegetables contain fibre but the cereal fibre found in whole grains is most closely associated with reduced colon cancer risk, Prof Miller added.

“There are many positive studies showing that a lack of cereal fibre is associated with increased risk of colon cancer,” she said.

A whole grain retains its original form, with the bran, germ and endosperm remaining. Many products, in particular bread, remove the bran and germ.

“The bran layer is where all the micronutrients are concentrated, so it does not make sense to throw out the bran,” Prof Miller said.

One body of thought is that when people consume carbohydrates without fibre it quickly raises insulin levels and the insulin stimulates the growth of mutant cells, such as colon cancer cells.

The science is unequivocal when it comes to diabetes and cardiovascular disease.

Professor Jennie Brand Miller
“Insulin is this anabolic hormone that doesn’t distinguish between good cells and bad cells, so the insulin is increasing the multiplication of mutant cells and sort of acting like fertiliser,” explained Prof Miller.

When you ingest the whole grain, she says, the body benefits from the “full compliment of micronutrients and antioxidants” like Vitamin E and C, which help slow down the process of free radicals.

The report also supports consuming whole grains for weight control among the overweight and obese and calls for multifaceted efforts to increase whole grain consumption.

AAP


(Marie Dantoni) #18

“Very noisy”? No kidding !


(Chris) #19

It’s unbelievable what lengths people will go to to try and discredit a low carb diet, they must be starting to get worried if they have to hit main stream media with releases like this to try and add to their scare campaign


(Chris) #20

Shhhh


(Bacon is a many-splendoured thing) #21

Huh. The Harvard School of Public Health must still be getting a lot of its funding from the sugar industry. Willett was one of of Frederick Stare’s students, and Stare was a good friend of Ansel Keys’.


(Chris) #22

You can’t tell me that a group of scientists and dietary luminaries who are part of a Consortium such as this just may have their moral and scientific compasses ever so slightly off true North. Call me a sceptuc


(CharleyD) #23

It is. It just isn’t in quite the direction his benefactors would prefer. Or else it doesn’t mean what he thinks it means.


(Bacon is a many-splendoured thing) #24

You’re absolutely right. How could I ever have doubted their motives? :rofl:


(VLC.MD) #25

In a bid to increase profits.

Here they are
http://carbquality.org/#about

Sponsors:
Fruit Juice association
Nestle
General Mills

I like how their website has zero studies. Essentially zero content.
Pretty big tell there.


(CharleyD) #26

So Scare Tactics, Appeal to Emotion, Appeal to Authority.

Are they interested in nutrition or running for office? :money_mouth_face:


(Duncan Kerridge) #27

A macronutrient has a lobby group?


(VLC.MD) #28

LOL.

We cant let the other macronutrients suffer !

We need to start a Fat Quality Consortium

Domain available !!!


(VLC.MD) #29

Homepage graphic … already made.

org


(Olivia) #30

“…in fact the research is very clear that when you include whole grain it is associated with lower risk of cardiovascular disease, diabetes and of weight gain”
I don’t think there is anything wrong with that statement. They are most likely suggesting a replacement of refined carbs with unrefined whole grains.

“…cereal fibre found in whole grains is most closely associated with reduced colon cancer risk”
Based on a quick sciencedirect-overview, that also sounds quite reasonable.


(Dan Dan) #31

Ok, I am dumb as a rock and have a low I.Q. but the consensus was that high starch, high sugar and low fiber causes high insulin with long duration and increases the chances of developing diabetes, cardiovascular disease and colon cancer :thinking:

Isn’t this a HCLF diet :thinking:

And a diet with “quality carbohydrates” “a full compliment of micro-nutrients and antioxidants” those low in starch and sugar, and high in fiber is associated with good health :thinking:

And this is a low carb diet :thinking:


(Duncan Kerridge) #32

No grains > whole grains > refined grains


(Marie Dantoni) #33

Study of one: My arthritis cleared within 10 days of quitting “healthy” whole grains.


(Duncan Kerridge) #34

I was discussing diet with my vegan nephew the other day, we were talking about refined carbs. ‘I avoid refined carbs’ he says, ‘my diet is full of whole foods - lots of veg, soy and pasta. I avoid bread’. I pointed out that pasta is made from flour like bread and he said it was ok because it’s whole wheat flour…

You can’t refine a food much more than turning it to dust so that the body can actually digest it.


(VLC.MD) #35

Look at the bogus story by these carbquality.org jokesters.

KF thread


(Sophie) #36

If grains are so good for you, why must the products made from them be “fortified” and “enriched”?!?! :roll_eyes: