That is the only red meat item I can massively overeat… I had other things too, though, when I had 1000g pork shoulder on TMAD carnivore, twice. I don’t even like pork shoulder much, it is just triggering for some reason. Other red meats work better. If I overeat, the meat part is still okay, I just eat too many eggs or too much dairy, usually both. So I try to focus on meat and whenever I have pork shoulder, I make sure it’s not my main meat.
But I am unable to eat only meat, that very quickly results in starving while having a serious meat aversion so eating meat is impossible. WHY I have this idiotic thing I don’t know, one is supposed to be able to eat meat (or any other proper food) when hungry but I am not like that. Once I even forced it and I gagged and had to stop.
My need for fuel, hunger and appetite aren’t very well synchronized But it’s still better on a mostly red meat diet than otherwise (the problem arises when I get too easy satiation and get hungry too often). I have great days there. And hungry days. And meat boredom days but those got very rare. And 5MAD days (eating 2-3 meals always was enough on every woe but carnivore is special).
I had enough so I go for no food until 4pm now (it suits me anyway, that’s actually a requirement for it). That should solve most of my remaining dietary problems.
We just need energy and protein. It means enough fat too, automatically. We can’t eat too little fat as we need the energy and we can’t get that from protein. I don’t think there is much more about it but it may be for some who need more fat and less protein. I need high protein (in grams and percentage alike) and little energy (hence the high protein percentage) so of course my fat percentage is lower.
I don’t know what people do when they need a higher fat percentage for therapeutic reasons or something but they need high protein and not much energy… Maybe they still eat much and use up it all and probably can’t lose fat until they heal somewhat? Or they are more magical than I am and still can lose fat… Whatever, I am glad I don’t strictly need very high fat, merely would love eating like that. I need high protein though and it’s non-negotiable - but I will try to lower it on OMAD if I ever manage to stick to it for more than 1-2 days without a ton of carbs. (I probably could do it on keto too if I really put my mind on it).
Our protein need is firmly in grams, NOT in percentage though. Or you say I need 3 times more protein when I eat a lot versus when I eat little? Nope, I need about the same. The grams are the important things here. Even for protein toxicity, it’s grams (compared to LBM or something but LBM should have the most to do with it. activity too, to some extent).
- Satiation has no effect on the tastiness of my food though.
- Fat doesn’t satiate me well. Of course I need it as I can’t and shouldn’t eat a ton of protein (and I don’t like lean protein. if protein is more than fat in grams, things get tricky as I prefer fattier than that - or did, my training starts to pay off) but beyond that… Nothing. After I had decent nutrition, I can add 100-200g fat and my satiation typically stays the same. I don’t even get full (that’s good as I dislike being full but maybe that would help me to stop). That’s why I need to minimize fat, I just don’t have a stop sign with it or I suppose I have but that’s over twice of my energy need. I need my protein and as little fat as comfortably possible (it’s a win if it’s below my protein, I really can’t eat lean).
It would be a bad idea for me sometimes but I can’t do it anyway I just can’t. Try and fail, regularly. Oh well, it’s not really a problem for me. And I do have weeks without any hunger but a very strong urge to refuel. I MUST eat then. So it’s not so simple for everyone. But as long as we figure out ourselves and can handle our signs well, it’s okay.
Lucky. I am a hedonist, food is one of my major joys and I have days when I have huge appetite when I don’t need food (so it tastes great) after I ate all day joyless food when very hungry. Not my typical behaviour, thankfully but happens too often.
I measure and try to put 450-600g meat in front of me and eat only that much fresh meat on a day. It’s not so bad, some people never are hungry, easily undereat, some manage to get protein toxicity and need to eat purely according to plan. I am usually fine but to be safe, it’s better to know when I had enough protein and fat. As it’s ridiculously easy to overeat both, I blame my overeating past. My actual diet helps a lot - but I still have those tendencies, some days are safe, others not and the average keeps me fat.
@Vnfo: Good luck to find the balance, not too much fat but enough to feel okay! And exercise has so many benefits, I encourage you to do some! I can’t force myself either, maybe I push myself here and there but basically just do what I like to do, walking, little cycling, lifting because I like muscles… A little is better than nothing!
Yes! Often, at least, if I stop, I need to restart as it’s so bad without. The more sedentary I get, the less energy I have as well, it’s horrible as I have little to begin with. Mood, energy, many other things, exercise is super useful, I consider it vital for health. It is clearly that for mine, physical and mental, emotional alike.
And if one has much fat, there is the extra muscle to move the bigger body. It would be a shame to lose that along with the fat…
We have threads here regarding exercise, strength training, lazy me find them motivating sometimes do I already am motivated as I clearly see and feel the benefits!