I don’t know if there is a catch, but I hope not since my dinner was just 1/3 pint of the Rebel peanut butter fudge. (Not something I normally do, but I enjoyed the heck out of it.)
I can’t imagine finishing a whole pint in one sitting because, for one thing, it freezes like a rock. They say to leave it out 15 minutes before eating. They lie. The center of the pint was still solid after 30 minutes. It is a test of patience! One I fail every time. Once it thaws it is creamier, but I can never seem to wait long enough. I just scrape at the edges that are more melted.
I find these things sweeter now, so that is a thing. I generally have had enough after a half cup to cup. Doesn’t take much. Although I gave it the old college try tonight.