Baking with erythritol - does it lose some of it's sweetness in the process?


(Brian) #1

I made some muffins last night, keto muffins. They’re pumpkin muffins with a cream cheese filling that’s put in there before baking. Both the muffin part and the filling part are sweetened. I used Swerve, which is erythritol for the cream cheese part of it and Pyure, which is a blend of erythritol, xylitol, and stevia, for the cake part.

I tasted the batter before I put it in the pan. Tasted good, plenty sweet. I tasted the cream cheese filling, plenty sweet. I thought to myself, “this is gonna be good”.

Baked it last evening but didn’t taste one of them until today at lunch, a treat for after lunch. Briefly warmed it in the microwave. Kinda tasted like I had left the sweetener out of 'em. It was a wonderful texture. And the flavors that were there (pumpkin, in particular), were fine. They weren’t bitter as some artificial sweeteners can do. They just weren’t very sweet. I didn’t notice either the cream filling or the cake part of it being any sweeter or less sweet than the other part.

Hmmm. :frowning:

It made me wonder whether this is typical for artificial sweeteners going through the baking process. Would a better plan be to sweeten until it’s a bit too sweet and then bake? Or if that just the nature of the beast?

I figure some of you have been down this road before so I figured I’d ask here.

Thanks!


#2

I think it does, in my experience. So I always add some stevia drops to a recipe with erythritol before baking, and when it tastes a bit too sweet, it tends to come out about right.


(Brian) #3

Thanks, gatita! I appreciate the feedback!

I’m just gonna have to try to remember to add that little extra.

:slight_smile: