No, I’m saying people can get fat just the same on LCHF, people do it all the time, I’ve put on plenty during the years when doing strict keto, including some intentional bulks, which right there proves we can gain weight on it. What you eat can have effects, some things are more likely to make you fatter than others, but when you’re eating lots of fat, which is over twice as calorie dense as protein or carbs, it adds up real fast. Then add the fuel to the fire that like many, my hunger/satiety signal are crap. I’m far from the only one with that issue. It’s a recipe for disaster. It took me over a year of not moving to drag myself in and actually have my RMR measures, just to realize my already low (for my life) calories where almost overshooting my metabolic rate by almost 1000! Correct that, and the year long stall started correcting the first week. That was still when I ate super strict keto, and after years of it. Also lost over 100lbs doing that, and then fasting, and then of course demolished my RMR, which I blame on the fasting. Plus the muscle loss.
By that logic so does hormones, stress, Insulin etc. They ALL matter. Our metabolisms are complex as hell, it’s not a single moving part situation. But the fact CICO isn’t perfect doesn’t change that, neither is our views on insulin, especially in the keto world. How many think it’s evil and forget that it does way more than be the “Fat storage hormone”. It’s way more than that. All the people on the GLP-1 agonists are losing fat, their blood sugars are way down, their fasting insulin is down, and all from a peptide that makes you release MORE Insulin at meals, keep in mind that’s in Insulin resistant and Diabetic people!
All of it matters, how much one outranks the other, is individual IMO. My bodyfat is lower now than it’s been in 15yrs. That’s after being at my worst, the initial loss, the stalls, and the largest drop in bodyfat and regaining my lost muscle from stupid moves prior, was since switching to TKD/CKD. It’s not as simple as carbs = getting fat.
Everybody (ok not everybody) in Keto circles is typically very familiar with the term Biggest Loser Syndrome, we see it all the time, usually in ourselves at one point, and many newbs come to the WOE, nobody has an issue pointing out that chronic hypocaloric diets kill our RMR, and then we gain when we even think about eating like a normal person again, hence why chronic calorie deprivation is a bad way to achieve a long term goal. One problem, you can’t say then, then say CICO is irrelevant, can’t have your cake and eat it too. Can’t say it works, but only in one direction. That was one of the things years ago that had me start questioning the keto hive mind and probably the biggest driver in getting me to go have my metabolic rate checked.