Maybe because those email settings were set to “Never” when you created this topic.
Are you getting the Daily Activity Summary?
Did you start your Acid Reflux post after adjusting your email settings and if so, are you getting emails for the Acid Reflux post?
Maybe on first suggestion, no on Daily Activity Summary, Yes, on my post today on Acid Reflux. No I haven’t gotten one thing in my email since I did the settings you see in the pics I posted 
But…if I click on the one here on site in my Profile Pic, I don’t think they send one to email. So I’ll try waiting a few minutes.
Just realized I also used to get emails that notified me of responses or action on a thread I was part of. The difference is I am glad they are gone now. Seemed like an unnecessary nuisance, since I check the forum semi-regularly anyway.
I don’t always so I miss getting them. Your an admin so I can understand it being over-kill for you Robin. Btw, I’m still not getting any so I don’t think it’s on my end at all.