Does dietary lactic acid affect ketosis like carbs?


(Marc) #1

I love yogurt, and understand that the bacteria in yogurt break down the lactose from milk into glucose and galactose, and then break down those two sugars into lactic acid. In theory, there should be no remaining sugar in plain yogurt, so long as the bacteria have been given a chance to do their work. I also understand that the carbs listed on the nutrition label of yogurt containers are calculated using the “difference method”, and are based on the macro-nutrient makeup of the input milk ingredients before the bacteria have their little nibble on the sugars - this may be different in some countries, but nonetheless there are plenty of carbs listed on the label which may in theory not be there at all after fermentation.

However, even if all the sugars are fermented, I am having trouble finding info on what the body does with the resulting dietary lactic acid in yogurt. Is this a source of energy, and is it converted into glucose by the liver or in some other process, perhaps in a similar way lactate is converted into glucose by the liver during intense exercise?

This of course only applies to plain yogurt, and not the many products with sugars added. I also understand that plain Greek yogurt may have less unfermented sugar, as Greek yogurt is drained to achieve that lovely thickness and often the sugars depart with this liquid.

So what is the verdict on plain yogurt and lactic acid - is it keto-friendly?


(8 year Ketogenic Veteran) #2

I don’t have any science for you other than my observation that some people have a hell of a time with dairy and keto, and others do not.

Something about the lactose jacking blood sugar up.


(Dustin Cade) #3

I would really like to see some science on this… I don’t personally like yogurt, but my lady and oldest boy does…


(Michael Wallace Ellwood) #4

This is from memory of what Steve Phinney has either said, or written (or both). I think he said that most of the lactose ends up as lactate (rather than lactic acid, or perhaps via lactic acid), and that this lactate can actually be burned as fuel.

The number of carbs on the label of the yogurt represents the carbs in the original lactose in the milk, rather than what you end up with. However, I think there will still be some carbs left - just not as much as you might think from the label.

(FWIW, I seem to be one of those affected by dairy, which is a shame, as I love dairy).


#5

Notice how water pools in the yogurt container, at the lowest spot? That’s where a lot of the lactose ends up. Drain the “water” out, and you reduce the lactose content in yogurt. If you wrap the yogurt in cheese cloth and let it drain further (making extra thick paste), there is even more lactose removed. I’ve also used a salad spinner and exploited the centrifugal forces to dewater yogurt in less time than hanging it in cheese cloth for hours.