Breathalyzer results when driving


(Colin) #1

If I get stopped by the police while driving and asked to do a routine breathalyzer test, I’m concerned that it may show a ‘false positive’, as breathalyzers may not distinguish between alcohol and ketones in the breath.

Does anyone have any advice on this front? I live in the UK, and I’m planning on driving in France in August.


(Paul H) #2

My first thought is demand a blood test but, I am in the US so not sure if you can in other countries… I would think so. Anything analyzing air is not going to be as accurate as blood.


#3

The type of sensor in the meter law enforcement uses (fuel cell or infrared spectroscopy) is different from the cheap breathalyzers which can be triggered by breath ketones (semiconductor).

https://www.expertlawfirm.com/ketogenic-diets-diabetes-breathalyzer-false-positive/

[edit]
Apparently isopropyl alcohol can be generated in severe cases like DKA, which isn’t the same as the breath ketones a normal healthy person makes.

someone suffering from DKA might not only “blow” a high BAC on a DUI breath test, he or she might appear drunk. Thus a law enforcement officer who is not a diabetes expert could easily arrest such a person for … Driving under the influence of alcohol… https://www.shouselaw.com/ketosis.html

Of course, this is based on U.S. breathalyzer testing but are they different in the U.K.?


(Colin) #4

Yeah, I don’t know. I think I’m right in saying that if you’re over the limit on the roadside test, they make you go to the police station to give another sample on a better machine. I imagine the roadside ones are less sophisticated than the station-based ones. Either way, your information is reassuring, so thank you.

In France, one is legally obliged to keep some type of breathalyzer in the car at all times. I wouldn’t expect them to work very well on someone in nutritional ketosis!


#5

Whaaaaat? I had no idea.

Even if you make it past the second phase of testing it sounds like a huge hassle.