Majority of parents will toss home made items, it it isn’t factory sealed, parents won’t allow the kids to have it. They are protecting them, ironically, by allowing them sugary treats from a factory. DUMB. That is why I am going with non food items.
When I was a kid, we got popcorn balls, homemade fudge, brownies, cookies, cake squares, factory candy was just not happening in our rural town. Sugary treats for sure, but they were made from real food and not a bunch of chemicals added to it.
If you live in a neighborhood that has moms who allow their kids to eat homemade items, it is a rare one and you have trusting neighbors, a blessing these days.
I don’t know masses of kids but my 3 nephews and niece all adore stickers and I bet would love things like little novelty erasers, etc. In fact, the treats they got when we stopped at the service station this weekend was money to get one of the balls out of the machines that contain little figures - Winnie the Pooh, puppy in a tin, etc.




I was shocked to say the least! He took some time in composing his response to me, which was, kids want/expect candy at Halloween, not nuts or any other stupid thing! It took me a few mins to realize that he is the one to eat all the leftovers that we don’t ditch on the neighborhood.
Needless to say, I bought a mega-bag of chocolate bars. Keto is a lifestyle, not a life sentence. You have to pick your battles.