Tomorrow 30 days, defeated - 3 months later, victorious!


(You've tried everything else; why not try bacon?) #21

I’m really sorry you’re feeling so bad, but four weeks is nothing in terms of a life-long way of eating. Fat adaptation generally takes about six to eight weeks, and sometimes longer, in any case, so I doubt you are doing anything wrong. If you could give yourself a bit more time, you might be pleased with the results.

Women in particular are conditioned to care strongly about scale weight, and if that’s true for you, perhaps you could learn to let that go. The reason is that keto is a health-normalization diet and gives many benefits in addition to the loss of excess fat.

Not only that, but we often use the word “weight” when what we are really talking about is “fat.” It’s fat that we really want to lose, not necessarily weight per se. As several women have already pointed out in this thread, women often gain lean tissue at the same time as losing fat, and the lean gains can cancel out the scale movement from the fat loss. This is by no means failure, it is vastly increased health. So if your clothes are feeling a bit looser, don’t worry about what the scale says.


#22

x


#23

There may be something in the shakes that could be causing issues. I would try to eat real food and ditch the meal replacements. If you drink coffee adding a little butter (cream if you do dairy). It use to hold me over well in the beginning. I have been very slow to see anything on the scale lately but work pants that were tight a couple weeks ago fit awesome this morning. Best of luck!


(Bob M) #24

Here’s three years of my weight data.

Over this time, I had shoulder surgery (right after the big dip). I was losing muscle mass before shoulder surgery, and continued to do so afterwards, though my weight went down (my muscle did too). The rapidly rising part at about 400 was due to regaining lost muscle mass. I had DEXA scans done, gained 4 pounds of muscle, lost 6 pounds of fat in a YEAR, for a grand total of 2 pounds of scale weight. I’m down around 50 pounds overall, and have vastly improved strength and now workout 3 days a week and have no IBS, no GERD, no allergies (was taking 2 24 pills per DAY), vastly improved heart failure, went from 43 inch pants to 36 inch, etc., etc.

Keep calm.


(Heather~KWOL for life!) #25

I am all about the heavy whipping cream in my coffee in the morning, and it helps me with the fat intake. Thank you.


(Heather~KWOL for life!) #26

Thank you, I appreciate everyone sharing. It means so much to me :heart:


(Heather~KWOL for life!) #27

I really am reading and processing the different comments and experiences, much of which makes a lot of sense to me, and is helping me look at it from a different perspective. I did not expect to lose loads of poundage, and I really do feel better and yes my clothes are hanging differently. I meant it on other posts that my health was most important, but at 30 days I would have liked to have at least seen a solid 1-3 lb loss. I will do measurements again, I did start that 2 weeks ago. I am not attached to the scale, but admittedly, for the 30 days, I was disappointed by the scale. Also, I had a really bad day yesterday and that was the icing on the proverbial cake, so I lashed out at keto. Because I am not perfect, and I couldn’t lash out at the other issues that had presented throughout the day. So, when I have more free time (am at work and not supposed to be online, oops) I will give a better picture of myself. I thank everyone for the amazing support, I did not expect that, thank you from the bottom of my heart.


(You've tried everything else; why not try bacon?) #28

That is litterally what we are here for. Pass it on when your turn comes, okay? In the meantime, keep on ketoing on, and keep letting us know what’s happening. :bacon::bacon:


(Heather~KWOL for life!) #29

I am going to stay with it, I guess I just needed to have my meltdown and share it. It was comforting that I am really not alone, and each of us have different paths to conquer. So, I have decided to stay with the forum, because I truly love it and the therapeutic milieu it provides. I will set my next goal at 60 days and I am going to opt to look at NSVs, as well as continue reading others posts and be encouragement to others.


(Empress of the Unexpected) #30

Thanks for staying - I’m at six months and tweaking things and learning something new every day. The forum has always been very supportive.


(Jane Reed) #31

Two years ago, when I started this way of eating, it took me 3 months to notice any difference in my body. During that time I did not own a scale so depended on a measuring tape and the fit of my clothes to tell me if I was dropping any fat. 3 months and nothing. But it happened.

Now I’m in a months-long stall. But there is no going back to grains and sugar. That way leads to disaster.

Hang in there…you may be one of the unfortunate few who lose fat very slowly. This way of eating means better health in the long run.


(Heather~KWOL for life!) #32

This morning I did a few quick measurements and I have lost 2 inches off my hips and 1 1/2 inches off my waist. My first measurements were 9/18. It could very well be less than that because my initial measurements I did in the evening :smiley:


(Carpe salata!) #33

:smiley:


(Raj Seth) #34

I don’t think measurements vary that much during the day - while weight does due to the capacity to carry varying amounts of water. So, net net, I think you have done OK. There is a reason so many say to get rid of the scale. The scale does not measure your body fat - just the total mass that stands on it, bones, muscle, organs and fat, all combined.
Seems like you may have lost some fat, and maybe gained some lean mass. Fat is less dense than lean body materials, so inches lost, but no weight change - this seems very very common amongst women doing Keto!


(Keto Kid 4 Life) #35

Glad you’re staying on Keto and on the forum! Your posts are valuable and you give great info! It can be discouraging, but feeling great is what keeps me on Keto. I can’t imagine doing anything else right now. All other “diets” left me unsatisfied and I still didn’t get results. An eating regimen that can help us lose body fat (no matter how long it takes) is worth it to me as long as I’m satiated and feeling good overall. You’ll get to where you need to be.


(Hyperbole- best thing in the universe!) #36

Most measurements don’t fluctuate, but the waistline does between morning and evening. Maybe not if you are fasting.


(Doug) #37

Yes indeed. In the late evening (when I’m dreaming of myself at a much younger age, or some other happy horse hockey) my waist is such-and-such a size. When I wake up in the morning, it’s half again as big!


(Janet Harris) #38

I too am feeling some what discouraged. Strictly no grains or sugar. Glad to read I’m not the only one with slow weight loss…I’m 64 and metabolism is nil!
I HAVE been pleased that my IBS issues are basically resolved…living without constant bloat is a blessing as are my GERD problems to a greater extent. I’ve had these problems since teenage days!!
I think I have to watch my Macros as I may not b achieving the correct %.
Using Carb Manager.
Thanks for all the great advice and support on this Forum!
Oh, just started collagen for joint issues xx


(Running from stupidity) #39

Well, that sounds like a massive win.

I think I have to watch my Macros as I may not b achieving the correct %.

Carbs under an absolute 20g is the key more than percentages.


(Heather~KWOL for life!) #40

I am no longer defeated…it’s a way of life I actually love very much and I hope that everyone finds what they need here! :grin: