Just some guy? What does it matter?
Information should be evaluated based on the content of the information, not on the authorship. It is a logical fallacy, an argumentum ad verecundiam, to assert that something is true because it is presented by an authoritative source or that something is false because it is not.
If multiple doctors are expressing different, contradictory, opinions, then it is obvious that at least some of them are wrong despite being doctors. Even if all the “experts” are presenting the same opinion, it might well be that all of them have it wrong. What if “just some guy” states a view that is contradicted by “just some doctor” and you dismiss his view based on credentials while there may, at the same time, be many other academics that are in complete agreement with “just some guy” of whom you are ignorant?
Dr. Ansel Keys was, well he was more than “just some doctor.”
I grew up in a family of scientist, professors, so I know that they far from perfect, often pompous, prideful, human, often wrong, sometimes dishonest, and at times wonderfully objective and intellectually honest. I would never dismiss the views of “just some guy” based on a lack of credentials, it is not in my nature, rather I ask if what is asserted is rational and supported by data, just like any objective scientist.
The diet of many hundreds of millions of people, likely billions, has been impacted negatively by the views of Dr. Ansel Keys, an establishment view, while any rational “just some guy” could easily observe that there are peoples around the world, the Inuit, the Massai and others, peoples completely devoid of all of the diseases of western civilization, who have been eating LCHF for a great many generations.
I find more veracity in the observation that “just some peoples” have been eating LCHF disease free for a great many generation then the views of “just some doctor”. That is I trust my own ability to reason, to think rationally, more then the views of “experts”, who, when they get it wrong, lead enormous numbers of lemmings over the cliff
I think it important that everyone at least attempt to think for themselves.
Eat like an Eskimo.
Keto for Life!
Respectfully,
Richard
[on edit] I apologize for the rant.